Construction Ireland Construction Directory
Time and date
CONSTRUCTION DIRECTORY
Share this page
Construction News
06/12/2011

Wilson 'Overturns' Lords Asbestos Ruling

A crippling illness that has hit many people who were working in the construction industry is being tackled with new legislation on compensation.

People suffering from the asbestos-related lung condition pleural plaques - usually contracted in the building sector - will be able to seek compensation from next week due to new legislation.

The NI Finance Minister Sammy Wilson said the legislation to allow workers to pursue claims and noted that the Stormont Executive has already set aside £2.5m for claims.

The legislation reverses a House of Lords decision of 2007, which ruled victims could not claim compensation with Minister Wilson now saying that the Damages (Asbestos-related Conditions) Act (Northern Ireland) 2011 will come into operation on 14 December.

He confirmed that the purpose of the 2011 Act is to reverse the decision of the House of Lords in Johnston v NEI International Combustion Ltd and conjoined cases 2007. In that case, the Court had ruled out the possibility of a claim in negligence for asymptomatic asbestos-related pleural plaques.

The corresponding legislation in Scotland was the subject of a long-running challenge, which was initiated by insurers and which came before the UK Supreme Court. On 12 October 2011, the Supreme Court rejected the insurers' claims that the legislation infringed their human rights and was outside the competence of the Scottish Parliament.

-- Advertisement --

The 2011 Act specifically provides that asymptomatic asbestos-related pleural plaques and certain other asbestos-related conditions constitute actionable personal injury.

This means that, from 14 December 2011, people in Northern Ireland will once again be able to claim compensation in respect of those conditions.

Mr Wilson said: "I am very pleased to announce the commencement of the Damages (Asbestos-related Conditions) Act (Northern Ireland) 2011.

"The challenge to the corresponding legislation in Scotland cast a long shadow and I fought hard to get the Northern Ireland legislation through the Assembly and submitted for Royal Assent.

"However, I always believed that the policy objectives of the Act were just and fair and that belief has now been vindicated by the ruling of the UK Supreme Court in relation to the Scottish legislation," he said.

"The 2011 Act may be short and targeted, but it is a vitally important Act, which seeks to ensure the continued availability of a method of redress for ordinary working men and women."

The Minister continued: "It must be devastating to be told that you have developed a condition as a result of having been exposed to asbestos. To be told then that you couldn't claim compensation for that condition would clearly make the matter worse.

"That was the effect of the decision in the Johnston case and it is not surprising that people affected by the decision sought redress through Ministers and the Assembly.

"The 2011 Act essentially reverses that decision and, whilst the ability to pursue a claim in damages will not fully compensate for any wrong which was done, I hope that those affected will derive some comfort from the fact that the wrongdoer can once again be held to account," he said.

Pleural plaques are small, localised areas of fibrosis found within the pleura of the lung caused by asbestos exposure.

Earlier decisions had established that it was possible for damages to be awarded for negligent exposure to asbestos as was often the case when men were working with the since banned asbestos materials on building sites or when involved in demolition of properties that contained the material.

(BMcC/GK)

Latest Construction News

20/11/2024

MDE has been awarded the electrical services contract for the Clondalkin School Development Project in Dublin. Working alongside Cunningham Contracts Ltd., the company will serve as the specialist electrical contractor for the construction of new facilities for Gaelscoil na Camóige, Gaelscoil ...
20/11/2024

In celebration of European Week for Waste Reduction, the Northern Ireland Resources Network (NIRN) has launched an environmental education programme to promote zero-waste principles among young people. Three schools from the ABC Borough—St Francis Primary School in Lurgan, St Patrick's Primary ...
20/11/2024

Work has begun at hospital sites across Northern Ireland as part of preparations to eliminate car parking charges by May 2026. Health and Social Care Trusts are installing the necessary infrastructure for a new traffic management system, following the passing of the Hospital Parking Charges Act by ...
20/11/2024

Fine Gael has accused Sinn Féin of abandoning its commitment to protect consumers from rising energy costs, claiming that the party's policies could lead to increased costs for 2.1 million customers. The criticism comes after Sinn Féin's alternative budget last month proposed retaining the ...
20/11/2024

SDLP Agriculture, Environment, and Rural Affairs Spokesperson Patsy McGlone has urged Minister Andrew Muir to take decisive action to protect the environment, rather than launching additional reviews. The comments came after Minister Muir announced a review into environmental governance during an ...
20/11/2024

Alliance Strangford MLAs Kellie Armstrong and Nick Mathison, along with Alliance East Antrim MLA Danny Donnelly, recently visited the tidal research experiment at Queen's University Marine Laboratory (QML) in Strangford. The project, funded by the Centre for Advanced Sustainable Energy (CASE), is ...
19/11/2024

Phoenix Energy has been awarded an international standards accreditation from the British Standards Institution (BSI) in recognition of its inclusive service approach for customers in vulnerable situations. The certification highlights Phoenix Energy's commitment to providing fair, flexible, and ...
19/11/2024

Seating Matters is investing £3.7 million to enhance and improve its manufacturing facilities in Limavady and L'Derry. The company is aiming to support its bold strategy to triple revenue by 2027. Making the announcement while visiting the company's Limavady site Economy Minister Conor Murphy ...
19/11/2024

SDLP Infrastructure Spokesperson Mark H Durkan has urged the Minister and the Executive to take immediate action to address problems within Northern Ireland Water. Mr Durkan warned that the current state of the wastewater system is creating significant delays for infrastructure projects across ...
19/11/2024

Galway City Council will hold a public information evening on affordable housing on Monday, November 25, 2024, from 4pm to 8pm at the Connacht Hotel, Old Dublin Road, Galway. The event will provide an opportunity for the public to learn about how affordable housing operates. Council staff will be ...
Snickers WorkwearToner Damp Proofing SuppliesACCON UK LtdKwik Floor ScreedRTS Heating & CoolingMaccaferri LtdAtlas Winch & Hoist Services (Southern) LimitedAPA Facade Systems (UK) LtdBDRs LimitedAC Cable Solutions
Terms and Conditions
2024/11/21 13:03:08